Convergence between Orthodox and Alternative Medicine: A Theoretical Elaboration and Empirical Test

@article{Bombardieri2000ConvergenceBO,
  title={Convergence between Orthodox and Alternative Medicine: A Theoretical Elaboration and Empirical Test},
  author={Dl Bombardieri and Gary Easthope},
  journal={Health:},
  year={2000},
  volume={4},
  pages={479 - 494},
  url={https://api.semanticscholar.org/CorpusID:71900519}
}
There is convergence between the practices of both therapeutic modalities evidenced by use of medical diagnostic procedures by alternative practitioners, use of alternative therapies by doctors and cross-referral of patients, but it is argued, such convergence is only weak.
View on SAGE
35 Citations
Highly Influential Citations
1
Background Citations
15
Methods Citations
1
Results Citations
1

Figures and Tables from this paper

35 Citations

Practicing Alternative Medicine in Israeli Hospitals

The paper discusses the early modes of entry into Israeli hospitals, the dilemmas faced and the mechanisms used to overcome barriers, as well as the mechanisms utilized to expand their presence in Israeli hospitals.

Complementary and alternative health care in Israel

The data are drawn from over ten years of sociological research on CAM in Israel, which included observation, survey research, and over one hundred in-depth interviews with a variety of CAM practitioners and policy makers in the major medical institutions.

Doctoring the Spirit: Exploring the Use and Meaning of Mimicry and Parody at a Healing Centre in the North of England

This article addresses the empirical example of a healing centre in the North of England, where an ethnographic study was conducted, and throws into question the conventional biomedicine/alternative medicine interface.

Towards the CAMisation of health? : the countervailing power of CAM in relation to the Portuguese mainstream healthcare system

It is argued that the relationship between CAM, the medical profession and the State has changed in Portugal over the last 16 years, and a concept is introduced that helps to explain CAM practitioners’ recent countervailing actions within the Portuguese mainstream health-care.

Therapeutic pluralism? Evidence, power and legitimacy in UK cancer services.

It is argued that the integration of CAM should not be conceptualised as a mere challenge to biomedicine, or, as resulting in a linear process of de-professionalization, rather, it should be seen as producing a complex array of processes, including strategic adaptation on the part of medical specialists and NHS organisations.

Mindfulness meditation as “good medicine”: a new epistemological pluralism in health care

It is suggested that although this process may look like institutional isomorphism with CAM therapies conforming to the standards of conventional medical institutions, institutional actors’ comfort with contradictions and hybridized views supports institutional heterogeneity and possibly even divergence.

‘Doctors Just Say “Rest and Take Ibuprofen”’

This article critically evaluates the extent to which non-orthodox care is an authentic ‘alternative’ to traditional medical approaches, and the contention that such treatment facilitates the continued presentation of self as both ‘athlete’ and ‘female’ at a time when these identities are challenged by the injury or illness experience.

Changing Boundaries: Modes of Coexistence of Alternative and Biomedicine

The authors used qualitative methods to analyze in-depth interviews in clinics and hospitals where alternative and biomedical practitioners work under the formal auspices of publicly sponsored biomedical organizations, showing an incursion by alternative practitioners into territories viewed until fairly recently as the exclusive domain of biomedicine.

Between formal and enacted policy: changing the contours of boundaries.

The Internationalisation and Hybridization of Medicines in Perspective? Some Reflections and Comparisons between East and West

The discussion aims for a reconsideration of Campbell’s theory, after Dawson, and offers a critical examination of a similar and parallel process: the “westernization” of Asian medicines.

34 References

The Response of Orthodox Medicine to the Challenge of Alternative Medicine in Australia

The Australian Medical Association has recently responded to this rise in the usage of alternative medicine by seeking to exclude alternative practices from funding by the government, but the success of this tactic is partly dependent on the government's response.

On the margins of the medical marketplace? An exploratory study of alternative practitioners' perceptions

The aim of this paper, drawing on data from an exploratory, qualitative investigation of the perceptions of alternative practitioners, is to examine the role and position of non-orthodox medicine…

Alternative medicine and general practitioners in The Netherlands: towards acceptance and integration.

A questionnaire on alternative medicine was sent to 600 general practitioners in the Netherlands and it was found that a majority of the respondents thought that these therapies included ideas and methods from which the regular methods might benefit.

The ‘eclipse’ of folk medicine in western society

It is argued that popular dissatisfaction with biomedicine has increased and that the cultural gap between biomedical practitioners and their patients has become much more visible in recent times which has contributed greatly to the secular expansion of folk therapies throughout western society.

Evaluation of holistic medicine.

Symptoms of a crisis? Trust, risk and medicine: review essay

The medical profession has long enjoyed the rewards of being a particularly powerful and respected source of expertise, but on the other hand, it appears to be increasingly under attack.

General practitioners and alternative medicine.

A questionnaire on the views, beliefs and attitudes of doctors regarding alternative medicine was sent to 274 general practitioners and found that over half of doctors believed that alternative systems of medicine were valid and over half defined alternative medicine as additional to western medicine.

Use of non-orthodox and conventional health care in Great Britain.

Patients of non-orthodox health care, as provided by this group of practitioners, had not turned their backs on conventional health care and used most frequently as a supplement to orthodox medicine.

Complementary medicine and the general practitioner: a survey of general practitioners in the Wellington area.

It is concluded that complementary medicine is of considerable interest to general practitioners; there is demand for more training and information to be made available for doctors and for better referral networks to be developed between the practitioners.

The use of alternative therapies by Auckland general practitioners.

A survey of Auckland general practitioners was undertaken to explore their use of, and attitudes to, alternative medicines, and Acupuncture was the therapy most commonly used.